Continuity mistake: During dinner, when Jess takes the beer from the fridge he walks out the kitchen's back door which has a lattice wall on the porch, and when Lorelai opens the same door, in the next exterior shot she's walking out the side living room door, onto the porch. (00:26:20)Super Grover
Continuity mistake: At the diner, when Lorelai stands at the counter telling Luke about Max's proposal, in the shots facing Lorelai we see the red ketchup bottle on the table behind her is either standing upright or lying on its side, changing a few times. (00:07:05)Super Grover
Continuity mistake: When Lorelai, Max, and Rory are in the diner, just as Luke tells them that he's almost out of the blueberry pancakes and he can't make more, the regular menu which is set upright on the table suddenly becomes the "lunch" menu, and then it's back to the regular menu. This occurs well before Luke even brings Max the lunch menu because Max is taking too long to decide. (00:13:35)Super Grover
Continuity mistake: When Emily, Lorelai and Richard are going to take the picture, Richard lifts his arm as if he is going to put it around Lorelai's shoulder. The angle changes and his hand is no longer raised. He then raises it again before finally lowering it.littlestar
Continuity mistake: When Lorelai and Rory get home from the upsetting dinner from Richard attacking Dean, while sitting at the table one shot shows the Twinkies arranged on the plate in front of Rory on the table. In a few other shots, you see a few twinkies missing and not arranged.