The One With Phoebe's Uterus - S4-E11
Corrected entry: When Phoebe goes to visit her birth mother in Montauk, her mom says "I wish someone would've been there to tell me how terrible it is to give up babies". The scene cuts to a shot of Phoebe holding the puppy, revealing a side view of a stand-in, not the actress playing her mom.
The One With The Worst Best Man Ever - S4-E22
Corrected entry: At the end of the scene where the duck is taking a bath, the bucket is on the old carpet. Monica removed the carpet in Season 4 episode 13.
Correction: There are two versions with the shots of the duck bathing in the bucket - the DVD version and the widescreen version (such as on Netflix). In both versions, when the guys are at the vet's office they're remembering past fun times with the duck, which includes the memory of the duck bathing. In the widescreen version, the last scene from the DVD has been cut and instead we just see a continuance of the earlier "memory" of the duck bathing, hence once again we see the old carpeting and also the guys' canoe.
The One With The Invitation - S4-E21
Corrected entry: Phoebe shows Ross' invitation to everyone, stating "Ross let Ben address mine." The envelope has poor kid like handwriting. The address is a 4 line address and the invitation also has stamps on it. When the camera comes back to Phoebe, she's holding an envelope with just her name on it, with no stamps. When she puts down the envelope by her side, the 4 line address is back. (00:11:30)
Correction: Yes, there are two larger envelopes, but they are not meant to be the same envelope, it's wedding invitation etiquette. The actual invitation itself is inserted in the "inner envelope" with only Phoebe's name written on it (or as 'Phoebe and friend'), and this inner envelope is inserted in the "outside envelope" along with the reply card (in the small envelope), and it's the outside envelope which is stamped and addressed to Phoebe ("4 line address"). We even see Phoebe holding both larger envelopes while removing the reply card's small envelope, just as Monica says, "This is so amazing," and also see them when Rachel opens her own envelope.
The One With The Embryos - S4-E12
Corrected entry: When the Gynaecologist says we insert 5 embryos for a 25% chance one will attach. Wouldn't one in five be a 20% chance?
Correction: That's not how the statistics work. There's no guarantee that any embryos will attach at all - presumably the odds of any one embryo attaching is 5%, so adding 5 makes the odds 25%. It has to be a balance between ensuring a vaguely decent chance of a viable pregnancy vs. the risk of having multiple babies. For example if they inserted 20 embryos to potentially "guarantee" at least one would attach, at least statistically, the odds would be much much higher of say 5 of them attaching, which would cause great complications for the mother and indeed the fetuses, not all of which would likely survive.
The One With Ross's Wedding, part 1 - S4-E23
Corrected entry: Emily, Ross and Monica walk past a black door, the shot changes to in front of them and back. When it goes back, the door is now a cream colour. (00:05:20)
Correction: None of the doors they pass are "cream colour" - every door they pass is black. It's all the window and door trim that are cream.
The One Where Chandler Crosses The Line - S4-E7
Corrected entry: Towards the end of the episode, when Chandler comes into the apartment to talk to Joey about his kiss with Kathy, Joey turns the TV off and places the remote on the counter. However, the TV is suddenly back on after Joey asks, "Is that why you bought all this stuff?" (referring to the furniture), and then Joey turns it off again manually. (00:17:10)
Correction: When Joey uses the remote he only mutes the TV's sound, and in the widescreen version we can see that "Wonder Woman" is still playing on the TV, then later Joey turns off the TV manually.
The One With All The Haste - S4-E19
Corrected entry: In this episode the chain on Rachel and Monica's apartment door is very long, but in "The One With The Late Thanksgiving" in Season 10, the chain is much shorter, causing Joey to get his head stuck.
The One With The Embryos - S4-E12
Corrected entry: For the game, there are 16 questions - 8 for each gender. When Ross says they have a tie, there are about 5 questions left on the board. Ross then goes to the Lightning Round and completely forgets about the other 5 questions. (00:07:30)
Correction: Ross says from the start that each team will answer ten questions. Ross has just made up more, in case one category is more popular than the others.
The One With The Dirty Girl - S4-E6
Corrected entry: When Ross is kissing the dirty girl on her sofa, he calls her Sarah. Then, when he kills the rat on her coffee table and thinks it was her hamster, he calls her Shelley.
Correction: Actually, he calls her Cheryl both times, which is the correct name of the character played by Rebecca Romijn.
The One With The Worst Best Man Ever - S4-E22
Corrected entry: In the scene where Joey tells Ross that the stripper stole the wedding ring, when Chandler says, "So you might say, it's a magic ring", you can see Joey starts laughing in the background. In the next shot he starts laughing again. (00:12:30)
The One With The Embryos - S4-E12
Corrected entry: During the guys' lightning round, when they give an incorrect answer they are given a new question. The girls however have to keep guessing at what Chandler's job is, even though Rachel has given an incorrect answer.
The One Where They're Going To PARTY! - S4-E9
Corrected entry: When Monica and Phoebe show the others the van, they are all standing on the curb. There is then a close up of Ross saying something and back to the wide shot. But now, Ross is standing in the road without having taken a step forward.
The One With Ross's Wedding, part 2 - S4-E24
Corrected entry: When Rachel is on the plane, it is shown from the outside to be a Boeing 747. When they get inside it shows only 2 seats over by the window. A 747 has a seating configuration of 3-4-3, with 3 seats by the window.
Correction: Virgin Atlantic uses 2-4-2 in Premium Economy, so 3-4-3 is not a rule, although it's the most common in economy on a 747. Surely the set is not an exact copy of a real plane, but the seating configuration is ok.
The One With Ross's Wedding, part 2 - S4-E24
Corrected entry: One best man (Joey) walks down the aisle with the mother of the bride and the other (Chandler) comes in with Monica which is completely wrong. The best man (or men) should be at the front of the venue with the groom - they are there to support him.
Correction: And there "should" be only one best man. There aren't any laws in weddings, so Ross can change it however he wants.
The One With The Worst Best Man Ever - S4-E22
Corrected entry: In the beginning, all the girls are eating sandwiches in the kitchen, Monica has a sandwich in her hand in some shots, but not in others.
Correction: But we see her pick it up and put it down in between shots.
The One With Rachel's Crush - S4-E13
Corrected entry: When Monica is talking to Rachel in the hall, when carrying in the vacuum cleaner, she is right in front of apartment 19. When Rachel opens the door to apartment 20 Monica doesn't appear to be there.
The One With The Dirty Girl - S4-E6
Corrected entry: When Joey slides the gift for Kathy across the bar, you can see in the bathroom that a towel is hung over the shower curtain rod, however in the shot when Chandler is saying goodnight to Kathy, the towel is gone. No-one went into the bathroom.
The One With Chandler In A Box - S4-E8
Corrected entry: During the scene when Phoebe tells Ross and Chandler she has to call her mom to ask her a left handed cooking question, the television behind Phoebe goes on and off between shots.
Correction: I've checked and it most definitely doesn't. It's on all the time.
The One With The Dirty Girl - S4-E6
Corrected entry: In the very first episode, Chandler says that between him and Joey they haven't had a relationship that lasted longer than a Mento. In this episode however, we find out that Joey went out with Angela Delveccio for three years.
The One Where Chandler Crosses The Line - S4-E7
Corrected entry: After Cathy gets off the phone with Joey, she puts the phone on the counter. A few shots later, when she starts to leave, the phone is on the receiver. After Cathy and Chandler kiss, the phone is back on the counter.
Correction: Sorry, I've watched this scene very carefully and the phone handset is standing upright on the counter during the whole time.
Correction: It is indeed Teri Garr in the side shot, not a stand-in.
Super Grover ★