Chapter Four: The Body - S1-E4
Continuity mistake: Right after Nancy puts together the torn photo of Barb at the pool it cuts to Dr. Brennan and crew in hazmat suits. At the beginning of the shot when they try to reach Shepard on the comms, the digital clock reads 6:54:08. After Brennan says "Try him again.", the shot has the clock blurred in the background as 6:40 something, and a bit later it reads 6:40:55. (00:27:20 - 00:27:54)
Chapter Four: The Body - S1-E4
Factual error: When Chief Hopper cuts open the fake body of Will, it appears that he opens a knife with a thumb assisted blade which wasn't invented until 1995.
Answer: The body was fake, made by the scientists at Hawkins Lab in an attempt to cover up his disappearance and the existence of the Upside Down.