Corrected entry: In the hospital scene towards the conclusion of the movie, Bella's nasogastric feeding tube isn't taped to her nose properly. As it dangles out of her nose, it is clear that the prop does not have the tubes going through her esophagus and into her stomach, as a real tube would. This misstep has actually led some people to assume it is some sort of breathing apparatus, which it is not. .
Corrected entry: Bella's hair is tied back in a ponytail throughout the entire baseball scene. When Laurent, James & Victoria enter, Bella's hair is suddenly loose.
Corrected entry: When Edward takes Bella to meet his family, it shows them cooking for her. They all look up, and Rosalie says, "Get a whiff of that" and then Esme says, "Here comes the human!" But Esme's mouth doesn't move: she just keeps smiling. It doesn't sound like Rosalie talking, so it has to be Esme that said it, but her mouth doesn't move from a smile. (01:04:40)
Correction: If you listen carefully, it's Rosalie saying both: "Get a whiff of that, " and, "Here comes the human." The voice matches Rosalie, as Esme's voice is much deeper than Rosalie's. It would also be completely out of character for Esme to refer to Bella as "The Human." Rosalie is known for continuously referring to Bella as "The Human" in a snide manner throughout both the books and the films, whereas Esme uses kinder nicknames (like dear, sweetheart and darling) as a way to make Bella feel welcome, like she belongs with them. Of course, Rosalie is always trying to do the opposite, and make Bella feel unwelcome, hence her saying "The Human" versus using her actual name.
Corrected entry: When they go on the school trip, Bella, Edward, Alice, and Bella's friends are there. They are all juniors. But Jasper is there and he is a senior. This couldn't even be a mixed trip, because Emmett and Rosalie aren't there.
Correction: In the movies, Jasper is the same grade as Alice. In the books, he is a year ahead of her. So in the movies you see Jasper with them in school. He is on the field trip, he is at school with Alice saying happy birthday in New Moon, he is at the cafeteria table when Alice has her vision in Eclipse as well as being at graduation with Alice. It was just a screen writer/director decision that is different from the book.
Also, in some high schools that do non-mandatory field trips, if a spot opens up a classmate can request to bring a student from another class, so even if he hadn't been bumped back a year for the movies, he would have been able to go on said trip. I don't believe the character of Jasper would spend a day at high school without Alice there.
Correction: In high school, it is possible for classes to be mixed grades. If someone needs a science credit, for example, a senior could be in a class with juniors.
Correction: Agree with the other corrections, but would add that the teacher, Mr. Molina, would likely teach more than one class for different grade levels. He could easily combine the different classes into one field trip. As there are two buses, it seems likely there is more than one class. Emmett and Rosalie may not be in any of Molina's classes. The field trip may also be optional for students to attend.
Corrected entry: When Bella "slips" on the ice, where she actually slipped, there is no ice.
Correction: You don't have to see ice for it to be there. I live in the same part of the country where the story takes place. It rains a lot here and the temperatures can then drop into freezing. Wet pavement develops a thin ice layer that is nearly invisible. It makes driving and walking extremely hazardous because it is hard to see. This is sometimes called "black ice."
Corrected entry: When Tyler's van comes skidding towards Bella, she is standing up against her truck. When Edward races next to her, she is crouching.
Corrected entry: Edward Cullen has a consistent accent in the beginning of the movie while in biology class, but does not have an accent for the rest of the movie (or series).
Correction: I would have to disagree that Edward has an "accent." When he first talks to Bella in biology class, he's struggling with his overwhelming desire for her blood, so his speech is a bit strained and deliberate as he attempts to control himself. Bella affected him so much that he was absent from class for about a week. He gradually becomes more comfortable around her and is able to talk more normally.
When he said, "So you're not worried because you'll be in a house full of vampires, but because they won't approve of you?" it does sound like he has an accent of some kind.
Corrected entry: During the baseball scene, when Carlisle is up to bat, he points his bat forward and in the background you can see Esme, Rosalie, Jasper and quite obviously Kristen Stewart's double with her hat pulled down low to cover her eyes. You can see it is a different person because her chin is quite square and Kristen's is very pointed. (01:17:05)
Correction: Actually, that's not supposed to be Bella at all, but Esme. You'll notice towards the beginning of the scene that, while Esme is wearing the solid white shirt that the actor in question appears in, Bella is wearing a dark brown jacket with a white collar, unzipped at the front.
Corrected entry: In the first biology lesson, Bella walks past the fan, and Edward's papers fly up. If the fan was in his direction anyway, his papers would have been flying up before Bella arrived.
Correction: The fan oscillates if you watch.
Corrected entry: When Edward jumps out of the window, he drags a tree with him, but he isn't very close to it. Also when Edward jumps, he stays level to the ground. Just because he is a vampire it never means that he can disobey the laws of gravity. (01:09:25)
Correction: So who made you the expert on vampires? They seem to disobey nature laws all the time; they don't age, go at superhuman speeds (or even faster) stop sliding cars by hand, just to name a few.
Corrected entry: When Bella is in the hospital and she looks for Edward, he has his head tilted to the right. When they show him again, he has his head to the left.
Correction: In the moment that the camera is off him, there's plenty of time for even a normal person to tip their head to the other side, much less a vampire who moves at lightning speed.
Corrected entry: In the cafeteria scene when Edward is not at school, Bella looks over to the Cullens' table. If you observe Rosalie extremely carefully, she takes something to her mouth and eats it as if she were human. She is a vampire, and she is not meant to eat anything. It happens again sometimes in other scenes. (00:14:40)
Corrected entry: During the prom scene, when Edward and Bella are walking in, it shows Victoria playing a game before it shows her watching Edward and Bella dancing outside in the promenade. She's got the same hair, fur shawl, dress, and necklace as she does when she's watching them dance.
Correction: How is this a mistake? She arrived before them, awaiting their arrival.
Corrected entry: When Bella is in the hospital (after her encounter with James) her mother comes in and explains what happened. She says that Bella had fallen down two flights of stairs and went through a window, which explains all of her concussions except for the bite mark on her arm. You can tell that people knew that there was a bite mark on her arm because it was all bandaged up.
Correction: Bella's mother was informed of a fictional account of what happened to Bella. Having a bandage on her arm doesn't interfere or contradict the story that she fell down the stairs.
Corrected entry: When Alice asks Bella if she'll be riding with the Cullens, Edward says the bus is full and steps inside, but when the camera faces Alice, Edward steps inside again.
Correction: No, he moves forward to "hit" the door so the driver will open it, and then he moves forward to enter the bus.
Corrected entry: In the scene Edward comes into Bella's room and kisses her, Bella is at first wearing sweatpants. Then she is wearing shorts instead when they kiss.
Corrected entry: In the scene at the hospital near the end of the movie, when Bella regains consciousness, she has flashbacks as her mother talks to her. But if you look over her mother's right shoulder (from Bella's perspective), you will see a television; showing the scenes containing the destruction of James and Bella tumbling down a flight of stairs, which are being played in a loop so that they could simply switch to a second camera to capture the flashback scenes.
Correction: This wasn't a mistake. They do this intentionally throughout the film. If you look closely at the rest of a room, a picture hanging on the hospital wall, is of the ballet studio, and there is a picture in Bella's room of a wolf, hinting at Jacob. Also, that television in the hospital shows clips of the home video of Bella when she is little. These are some hidden jabs and nods at the audience, and for people to pick out, not mistakes.
Corrected entry: In the Dance Studio, there is a point where James rams Edward's head into the mirrors, shattering the surface. However, Edward's reflection on the shattered surface remains intact, instead of being a fractured reflection, as would have been the case when a mirror shatters. (01:34:25)
Correction: This doesn't have to be a mistake. The glass in the mirror might shatter but stay in place, thus not fracture the image that much.
Corrected entry: During the baseball scene, Carlisle's scarf changes from plain gray to gray and black striped. It also goes from hanging loose to wound around his neck, then back to hanging loose.
Correction: This is not accurate. The second part is correct, but the first part isn't. It just seems grey because the camera is not focused on him, and the colours blur together.
Corrected entry: When Bella is asking Edward how he knew where she was in the restaurant, you can see the outline of her brown contacts.
Correction: Nothing in the movie ever reveals that the character of Bella doesn't wear contacts. Bella could easily wear contacts herself.
Correction: IT IS a nasal cannula delivering oxygen. It is NOT a nasogastric tube to empty the contents of her stomach.
shortdanzr ★