Corrected entry: How can Kenny afford a PSP? He is dirt poor and his family is constantly on welfare.
Correction: Not a error, lots of people on welfare have some nice things.
The Death of Eric Cartman - S9-E6
Corrected entry: At the end when Cartman finds out he's not really dead (everyone was just ignoring him), he storms over to Butters and accuses him of lying to him by telling him he'd died. But earlier on, when Cartman and Butters meet, Cartman's the one who told Butters he had died.
Correction: Cartman is a sociopath and can't ever admit fault: Butters didn't tell him he wasn't dead, therefore, it's all his fault.
Corrected entry: When Randy and Bat Dad are fighting, the referees run over saying that if they don't stop fighting, their team will be disqualified. But Randy is seen fighting in all the other Little League games, so why was South Park not disqualified then?
Correction: Because the refs finally had enough of Randy fighting with everyone, and threaten to disqualify the team.
Erection Day - S9-E7
Corrected entry: Jimmy says that he has spent all of his money on the prostitute. But then he exits the restaurant, gets directly into a cab, and later pays the cab driver in cash.
Correction: Jimmy was just exaggerating when he says he had spent all his money, as he was in the restaurant before having paid and how would he have paid there if he HAD spent all his money?
Corrected entry: If Mrs. Garrison hands out real eggs to the kids to use, wouldn't the eggs get rotten after not being refrigerated?
Correction: Unwashed eggs don't need to be refrigerated - in the UK at least, they're sold and stored at room temperature. If these eggs were freshly laid they'd last just fine.
Correction: With all the scientific improbabilities & impossibilities that occur within this series, it is very doubtful.
Corrected entry: When 'Batdad' makes his first appearance, and Sheila Broflovski asks who he is, a woman replies that his name is Tom Nelson, however in a later scene his wife refers to him as Chris.
Correction: Character mistake- the woman who identified Batdad as Tom Nelson simply mixed him up with someone else. On the verge of unlikely, given that he is somewhat of a celebrity figure in Denver, but still entirely possible.
Mr. Garrison's Fancy New Vagina - S9-E1
Corrected entry: When Kyle enters the basketball game as the tall, black kid, the game announcer refers to Kyle as number "8". He is actually wearing a jersey with the number "4" on it.
Correction: This isn't a show goof, it's a character goof: the announcer made an honest mistake.
Erection Day - S9-E7
Corrected entry: Why doesn't Jimmy know what to do with an erection? In episode 6-16: "My Future Self n' Me," he says that he and his girlfriend took ecstasy and had sex.
Correction: In "My Future Self n' Me", Jimmy was telling a joke. This is obvious because among other things, if he'd actually taken ecstasy then he wouldn't have been afraid to touch the marijuana. Jimmy presumably heard the "in her vagina" joke somewhere and just recognized it'd be funny in that situation.
The Death of Eric Cartman - S9-E6
Corrected entry: When Cartman is walking the streets thinking he's died, it's a school day since you see him visit the school swarming with pupils and he is seen waiting with the other boys at the bus stop. But if it's a school day, what's Butters doing at home? And if it's because he's sick, why is he outside shovelling the snow off the driveway?
Correction: Cartman sees Butters on an obviously different day. He leaves the school playground, crying, and eventually crosses a bridge during sunset. When he walks past a house, the sky is dark and stars are visible. In the scene with Butters, it is daytime again. This new day could be a weekend, holiday, or a day that the students have off for some reason (i.e. teacher meetings).
Correction: Butters' parents are constantly grounding him for one reason or another. They may have grounded him from school and had him do chores around the house instead.
It's actually a different day when Cartman talks to Butters. There were moments with a sunset and a starry night sky, then Butters is shoveling snow in the daytime.
Correction: Maybe the PSP, or the money for it, was a gift from a relative. Maybe Kenny's parents had extra money for some reason (i.e. gift, or winning a few hundred dollars from a lottery ticket). Maybe a store was offering a payment plan.