Continuity mistake: When they're handing out roses for the second time, when Jimmy gets his rose, we can see Craig at his left, having one too. But in the next shot, when they tell the ones that didn't get a rose to go home, Craig doesn't have a rose and has been eliminated from the competition.
Continuity mistake: In the classroom scene where Kyle tries to be excused from class to find Ike, Cartman sets Pip on fire as he was sitting just behind him to the the left. However in the previous shots Pip had not been sitting there, some other kid was and wouldn't have had enough time between shots to move. (00:09:05)
Continuity mistake: After Mr Garrison announces Kathie-Lee will be presenting an award for Cartman, you see the next scene in the Mayors office. There we can see cleary the curtains are red, then she looks out the window and looking in the office from outside, they are pink, but it goes in the office again and now they are back to red.
Continuity mistake: In the episode "Cat Orgy" when Sheily's boyfriend, Sklar, are playing the song for Sheily while Cartman is hanging on the coat rack you can see of what looks like a picture of Cartman's grandparents hanging on the wall. But when Sheily walks over and flings Cartman up into the ceiling for arguing with her, look at the wall, the picture is completely gone.
Continuity mistake: When Garisson tries getting his balls back from Kyle, a scene is shown in which a man in a suit is singing, prior to the basketball game Kyle is allowed to play, because of his negroplasty. In the background are all the basketball players, including Kyle, who should be black now. However the shot shows him in his previous white form, in his old jersey. (00:18:15)
Continuity mistake: When Eric comes running over to talk to the other 3 boys about the handicapped competition, their toy trucks are quite far apart from each other, but when it cuts from Cartman and then back to the boys, Kyle's truck has moved all the way in front of Stan's truck.