Corrected entry: When Legolas is hanging on the Mumakil, he cuts the ropes that are holding the saddle quite far down. But when he is pulled up you can see that they are cut far above, directly where the saddle ends.
Corrected entry: In Minas Tirith, when Legolas appeared at the door of the room Frodo rested in, his collar was open. (Check the close-up shot of Legolas.) But when he was inside with the other fellowship members, his collar was fastened. (02:52:10)
Correction: As Legolas walks in after Gimli, the top clasp on Legolas' high collar IS fastened - it is about 6 inches down from the top of the collar. The top corners of the collar material are merely angled out a bit in this shot. Then, it is after 2 shots of Frodo and 2 shots of Aragorn that Legolas is in the wide shot with everyone and the corners of the collar are straighter, which only required a flick of the finger.
Corrected entry: Sam and Pippin quite often sport 5 o'clock shadows, even though Hobbits do not have facial hair.
Correction: There are three types of hobbits: Stoors, Fallohides, and Harfoots. Only Fallohides are established to have no facial hair, the other two types may or may not. Who's to say that a five o' clock shadow is wrong? Also, in the books, Merry and Pippin grew taller and beards because of what Treebeard gave them to drink.
Corrected entry: When Sam picks up Frodo on Mount Doom after his "patriotic" speech, Frodo's head is on Sam's right side. In the next scene, where they see the doorway, Frodo's head is on Sam's left side.
Corrected entry: In the scene at Mount Doom when Gollum bites Frodo's finger off, he falls down in pain, next to Gollum. Then Gollum is ecstatic he got the ring, and it shows a top view of Gollum, and Frodo is several meters away from him.
Corrected entry: In the Two Towers, as the Ents are about to attack Isengard, they have to walk from Fangorn Forest to Isengard. However, in Return of the King, the two are right next to each other. It's not that the Ents have taken root again, because you can see them walking around in the background. It was probably done deliberately, so that Merry and Pippin could see them walking out of the forest, but still a mistake.
Correction: A scene restored to the extended edition of TTT shows the Huorns, which are moving trees but not Ents, arrive at Helm's Deep and stomp the orcs to death, when they flee into the newly formed forest. This scene from the book was deleted from the theatrical edition of TTT for reasons of length, but explains why the forest is closer to Isengard in ROTK.
Corrected entry: In the scene where Pippin finds Merry under an Orc, look at the dead Mumak in the background. The size is drastically reduced from all the battle scenes. The foot, for example, looks like it could hardly step completely on Merry, a 3'8" Hobbit, let alone entire Rohirrim horses. (02:17:20)
Correction: It looks the same size as it was earlier. A horse is not much longer than Merry is tall, and it does look like it could step on the Hobbit quite well. It is not at all drastically reduced.
Corrected entry: In the scene where Theoden rides into Dunharrow, he asks "Where are the riders from Snowborn?" the answer is "None have come, my lord"; this is impossible, since Snowborn is a river or stream passing right next to the Rohirrim encampment. What this means is that they cannot come since they would have already been there.
Correction: It doesn't mean anything of the sort. The Snowbourn River does indeed run past Dunharrow, but it then runs north and east across Rohan, past Edoras, until it finally meets up with the Entwash. The Snowbourn that Theoden refers to, which is presumably a settlement of some description that takes its name from the river on which it lies, could be anywhere along the route.
Corrected entry: Eomer shoots an arrow at an Oliphaunt. In the first shot, front view, it is missing nearly its entire right tusk (it shows a bloody stump). In the shot from the rear view, it has an intact right tusk as it falls. (This scene occurs immediately after the one in which Eowyn & Merry charge at, hack at, and down an Oliphaunt).
Correction: In the side back shot, only the two small bottom tusks, the long top left tusk and the Mumak's trunk (which may be mistaken for the long right tusk in the quick shot) is clearly seen. We do not see the long right tusk on the other side of the trunk, as it is a short stump.
Corrected entry: In the book The Hobbit, the three trolls that captured the dwarves are turned to stone by being exposed to daylight. The extended DVD of FOTR has a scene which touches on this. However, there are plenty of trolls fighting in the daylight battles in ROTK.
Correction: Different types of troll - the ones seen towards the end are Olog-Hai, a special breed of troll created by Sauron. They're stronger, more intelligent, and can survive in sunlight, unlike the common trolls of the type encountered in the Hobbit.
Corrected entry: When Aragorn, Eomer, Merry, Pippin, Gandalf, Legolas and Gimli ride up to the black gate, after Aragorn says his bit, there's a shot of Merry, then Gimli, then Eomer. You can see Eomer is wearing a red bandana or hat of some sort under his helmet. (02:24:25)
Correction: What's to say someone from Middle-Earth couldn't do that?
Corrected entry: When Théoden is knocked under his horse by the Witch-King, it's obvious that the Fell Beast is attacking so Théoden is looking down at him, with the horse's legs pointing at the Fell Beast, yet after Éowyn destroys the Witch-King and Théoden passes away, we see a wide-shot of the whole scene. Éowyn's discarded helmet and the remains of the Witch-King are positioned at Théoden's head rather than feet. The attack all took part below Théoden, so how did everything shift to above his.
Correction: Wrong. After Theoden dies, there is a wide shot of the area and the helmet near Theoden's head is his (use zoom if necessary) not Eowyn's. Plus the Witch King's remains are not near Theoden's head in this shot either.
Corrected entry: When Aragorn is releasing the Army of the Dead, in the background flags showing the white tree of Gondor can be seen (the same emblem that Aragorn wears on his armour at the black gate). Problem is, no Gondorian soldiers fought in the fields around Minas Tirith, so where did the flags come from?
Correction: They came from Rivendell. Arwen made them and Elrond (in the film) brought them. Though the sequence itself was not in the theatrical cut.
Corrected entry: At the Battle of Pelennor Fields Eowyn asks Merry to take hold of the reins. After he does she reaches out with her hand and grabs the spear of an on coming Orc. In the next shot it changes to a sword. (02:06:00)
Correction: It's not a spear she grabs. Look closely and you'll see it's a sword. The orc is holding it at the bottom. If it were a spear, the orc would be holding it farther up.
Corrected entry: In the shot where Frodo is hanging in Shelobs web struggling to escape you can tell that he has shoes on.
Correction: No, he is not wearing shoes. It is the outline of the ankle straps for the attached stunt wire, which is already noted.
Corrected entry: On all the closeups of the Ring in Mount Doom, there are numerous flashes in the chamber that look like lightning flashes, or some other form of "blue" light. There wouldn't be any light of that color in the chamber because it is all fire and lava.
Correction: It's a chamber that has seen substantial amounts of magic used there - namely the forging of the Ring itself. Who's to say what sort of odd discharges there might be, particularly as we're focusing on the Ring - the target of all that magic power.
Corrected entry: At Isengard when Pippin jumps off Aragorn's horse to retrieve the palantir, the water is up above his waist when he reaches into the water for the palantir. But when he hands the palantir to Gandalf, his top half is still dry.
Correction: Pippin only reaches his arms down below water and his sleeves remain wet throughout the scene.
Corrected entry: When Faramir and his men are overwhelmed by Orcs, they retreat to Minas Tirith. Gandalf, with Pippin astride, gallops out from Minas Tirith on Shadowfax and drives off the Nazgul and the fell beasts. There is no reason for Gandalf to have ridden out with Pippin.
Corrected entry: King Theoden tells Merry 'It is a three day gallop to Minas Tirith', but they arrive there the next day at dawn, as the siege of Gondor begins as they begin their ride, and the siege of Gondor goes on all night into dawn the next day, which is the time the Rohirrim arrive.
Correction: It is a three day ride from Edoras. Théoden and his men ride out from Duneharrow.
Corrected entry: On the DVD, in the scene where Gandalf is driving the carriage (with Frodo and Bilbo on board), in the zoomed out shot you can see four hobbits riding on ponies. There should only be three. Since Frodo is in the carriage, that would only leave Sam, Merry, and Pippen. These are the only hobbits going along, since they are the only ones at the harbor.
Correction: In the overhead shot, we hear Frodo's voiceover as Gandalf arrives in the wagon, and all four Hobbits are on the ponies. It then cuts to Gandalf's close-up. Next is a long shot, as we hear Bilbo's voiceover say, "Tell me again, lad, where are we going," and the four ponies have only three riders, one of the ponies is riderless, with Frodo inside the wagon with Bilbo. Use zoom, it is very clear.
Correction: The set of ropes that Legolas cuts are looped into circular openings at the base of the Haradrim tower. Once the rope is cut it snakes loose quickly due to the load that it holds, so as the tower falls the rope is no longer there. All that is visible is the tower and its base.
Super Grover ★