Elementary

Elementary (2012)

24 mistakes in season 1 - chronological order

(2 votes)

While You Were Sleeping - S1-E2

Other mistake: When Sherlock was slapped, he later says he was surprised because the girl who slapped him was a "lefty." Then he rubs his right cheek and says it's leathery from all the slaps he's gotten, while the left is soft. This is backwards - anyone hitting him with their right hand would hit his left cheek.

Cathrine R

Child Predator - S1-E3

Character mistake: The number of victims of the balloon man changes from seven to eight between the initial scene where he is introduced and where Holmes finds out the identity of the original balloon man.

The Rat Race - S1-E4

Continuity mistake: Watson has just been ambushed with a date by her friend at the very beginning. She is reaching for her coffee cup. In the immediate next shot, her hand is down by her side. (00:03:15)

One Way to Get Off - S1-E7

Continuity mistake: In the prison, Captain Gregson takes five shoes out of a suitcase, but when it comes time to leave, Gregson doesn't put the shoes back in the suitcase because they are already there, and he could not have done it without us seeing it.

kh1616

The Long Fuse - S1-E8

Continuity mistake: The brownstone has two front doors, an outer door and an inner door. In scenes before this one and after this one, the outer door is made of wood and the inner door has a large glass panel, at the top, but in this episode the outer door has a large glass panel, at the top, so they can see who it is before opening the door.

kh1616

You Do It to Yourself - S1-E9

Continuity mistake: Just before Sherlock and Detective Bell enter the dead professor's office, both are putting on gloves. Sherlock puts on the left first and has partially put on the right. As they enter the office, Sherlock still hasn't put the right glove on at all - he's just starting to do so. (00:05:30)

Cathrine R

The Leviathan - S1-E10

Continuity mistake: While playing the piano in Justin Guthrie's apartment, he is bare handed. In the next scene when he gets up to point at the blood, he is wearing gloves. (00:24:12 - 00:24:42)

The Leviathan - S1-E10

Other mistake: When Sherlock and Watson look at the coffee order from the trial it has the names of the 4 jury members who robbed the vault. Not the original men that did the robbery.

The Red Team - S1-E13

Continuity mistake: Early in the show, when Sherlock is making eggs, he adds milk and sets the jug down. The camera shifts to Watson and back to Holmes, which shows the jug missing. Watson then walks around Holmes and sets the jug down in the spot it was in previously.

Details - S1-E16

Character mistake: When looking at the car near the start, Sherlock says he can tell by the pattern of the bullet holes that the gun was fired in 3 round bursts. But when we saw the attack earlier, the gun fired in bursts of different lengths.

Jon Sandys

Details - S1-E16

Continuity mistake: When Joan meets with her therapist, the nook behind Joan is brightly lit. The nook goes back and forth from brightly lit to very dark, sometimes in the space of a three-second cut to the therapist.

Guy

Possibility Two - S1-E17

Character mistake: They are in the interrogation room questioning the fiancé of the scientist Natasha when the captain says, "the blood we found at the scene of your fiance's murder, it didn't belong to Bobby Cordero." The characters name was Benny Cordero, which the captain says correctly a few lines later. (00:33:25)

Possibility Two - S1-E17

Continuity mistake: Sherlock and Watson are riding in a limousine. They are seated on the back-facing seats of the limo. Thee are 2 passengers seating on the back seats. The street background visible through the back and side windows shows traffic and the limo moving forward. Some shots of Sherlock show the background traffic moving in the right direction (backwards) and one shot shows traffic moving in the opposite direction, as if Sherlock was seating on the back seat or the limo was moving In reverse.

ppdixx

Dead Man's Switch - S1-E20

Other mistake: Near the end of the episode Dr. Watson states, "Look at the time, happy 'real' anniversary." - referring to Sherlock's one year anniversary of sobriety. The scene then cuts to a flip clock. However, the clock is set to 12:07 PM - not AM as it would be if a new day had begun. (00:41:20)

Risk Management - S1-E22

Continuity mistake: While Joan and Sherlock are chatting, Joan is trying to make peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, but the shots alternate between the two and Joan repeats her movements, wipes the peanut butter over and over on the bread, and changes her mind with the jelly bread.

kh1616

More quotes from ElementaryMore trivia for Elementary

Answer: I'm the same person who asked this question. I discovered it was Molly Price whom I recognized from Third Watch.

Cathrine R

It should be noted Donna was Jim Fowkes‘ secretary. Donna killed Peter.

Bishop73

More questions & answers from Elementary

Join the mailing list

Separate from membership, this is to get updates about mistakes in recent releases. Addresses are not passed on to any third party, and are used solely for direct communication from this site. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Check out the mistake & trivia books, on Kindle and in paperback.