Continuity mistake: In "Sleepy Time" when the neighbours are crowded around Spongebob, Plankton is standing on the end of the bed. When the angle changes, he's gone. Then he jumps onto the bed before Patrick joins them.
Continuity mistake: In "Sleepy Time", Spongebob is driving a car in his dream. When he starts to drive faster, he sticks his tongue out on his left cheek. When he makes a left turn in the next shot, it's sticking out on the right cheek.
Revealing mistake: After SpongeBob disguises himself as Patrick's rock and right before he sneezes his uvula clips through his bottom lip.
Valentine's Day / The Paper - S1-E16
Plot hole: When SpongeBob goes to Sandy's house, he blows a chocolate bubble with the shape of a heart. Sandy opens a little door and the heart comes in. But, if the heart enters, don't you think that water would have also entered?
Valentine's Day / The Paper - S1-E16
Continuity mistake: In "Valentine's Day", Patrick starts searching his present in the fair. Then he goes to a mountain and falls thinking that there will be his present. This mountain wasn't there before, even when they arrived to the fair.
Valentine's Day / The Paper - S1-E16
Continuity mistake: In Valentine's Day, almost at the end, Patrick smashes some presents with his foot. After a while, Sandy arrives with Patrick's present (a chocolate globe), and you can see that the presents have dissapeared.
Valentine's Day / The Paper - S1-E16
Continuity mistake: In "Valentine's Day", SpongeBob and Patrick arrive at the fair. They watch the fair. Patrick says "You bought me a fair?", and Patrick runs to the fair. When he starts saying, "Get out of my fair.", we see that SpongeBob is closer to the fair than he was before.
Valentine's Day / The Paper - S1-E16
Continuity mistake: The Paper: The front door of Squidward's house repeatedly switches between opening at the right side and opening at the left side, and the round door knob also changes to a door handle as well, but then reverts back to the round knob.
Continuity mistake: In "Rock Bottom" when Spongebob is on line and the egg cracks, you can see the cracked pieces on the ground and then when he does his (in pants) "Barnacles, tartar sauce" you can't see the egg pieces.
Revealing mistake: At the beginning of Rock Bottom, when the bus pulls up in front of Patrick and SpongeBob, right before Patrick steps up onto the bus, SpongeBob's right arm is missing and it suddenly appears as he starts moving.
Continuity mistake: In the scene where Mr. Krabs is saying "this is no game" Spongebob is in his underwear, then it goes to Mr. Krabs and back to Spongebob and he's in his work clothes.
Audio problem: In the episode "Rock Bottom" when Spongebob says "Another funtastic day at glove world," near the beginning, if you watch Spongebob's mouth, it only says "Another funtastic day at." It never says "glove world."
Revealing mistake: Near the end of "Rock Bottom", when SpongeBob arrives back to Bikini Bottom, SpongeBob's pineapple is animated differently from the other buildings. It looks like it was cheaply tacked on in post production.
Continuity mistake: Rock Bottom: After SpongeBob and Patrick enter the bus, when SpongeBob asks Patrick if he has any change and for the duration of this shot, both the gear shift on the floor beside the driver and the open door of the bus have vanished, then they reappear.
Continuity mistake: When SpongeBob sees the kandy machine, the front of the machine is facing the road, but when he runs over to it, the front is now turned away from the road.
Continuity mistake: When SpongeBob and Patrick see the map, a compass is seen next to it. As the two start touching the map, the compass has disappeared.
Texas / Walking Small - S1-E18
Continuity mistake: In "Walking Small", The eel that stole Spongebob's ice cream cone throws it at his face. Different shots some show ice cream on Spongebob's nose, and some show that Spongebob's face is clean.
Fools in April / Neptune's Spatula - S1-E19
Continuity mistake: When Spongebob grabs Squidward's legs you only see him grabbing at two of Squidward's legs and the other two legs have disappeared, but when the shot changes they're back again.
Fools in April / Neptune's Spatula - S1-E19
Continuity mistake: In "Neptune's Spatula", Patrick takes a picture of SpongeBob holding the spatula. When this happens, we can see that SpongeBob is a little worried because clouds have appeared there. However, after a while, Patrick shows the picture to Neptune, and we can see that in the picture SpongeBob is smiling and pointing with the spatula.
Fools in April / Neptune's Spatula - S1-E19
Continuity mistake: Eventually after Spongebob takes the door wheel handle off, it comes back.
Answer: I believe this is the Season 6 episode "Spongicus".