Alien

Plot hole: When Ripley goes to access the computer Mother, the entry door opens and closes with a hissing noise, a couple of minutes later you see Ash next to Ripley with a smile on his face. How did Ash manage to open the same door without it making the hissing sound? Ash could not have been in the room before Ripley came in - once Ripley has sat down at the console, it rotates on a 90 degree angle, this would have made it impossible for Ash to be hiding behind a desk or a computer console without being seen by Ripley. There are many doors on the ship that make the same hissing sound when the doors open, an obvious example is the infirmary door. And Ash couldn't have disabled the pneumatics of the door, because when Ripley exits the room, the hissing noise is heard again. (01:18:40 - 01:20:00)

Upvote valid corrections to help move entries into the corrections section.

Suggested correction: There's no evidence that sound happens every time the door opens. It may be a pressure release sound, but not enough pressure has built up since Ripley opened the door to make the sound. It's like flushing a toilet twice in quick succession, before the tank has had a chance to refill. The action is the same, but the same mechanism is engaged; it makes a different sound.

Plot hole: The shuttle "won't take four" crew members. Considering it only has two cryotubes (and hypersleep appears to be necessary for any hope of survival), it doesn't seem to accommodate three people, either. (Admittedly I would still go for it, too, if I were up against a 7-foot-tall acid-blooded alien monster with two sets of jaws, but there doesn't seem to be much difference whether there's three or four people onboard).

TonyPH

Upvote valid corrections to help move entries into the corrections section.

Suggested correction: As was standard, the Narcissus (which was the name of the shuttle) was designed to carry a crew of three, although the interior could be easily modified to seat more crew members if necessary. For long-duration travel, the shuttle contained two stasis capsules, although long-range interstellar transit was not the vessel's primary purpose. So in a life-or-death situation, four people intending to use it to get off the Nostromo isn't a plot hole.

I'm not sure I understand the correction. The reason Ripley rules out escaping on the shuttle at first is because it does not accommodate four crew members. When she later changes her mind after they've destroyed Ash, the natural assumption is that the shuttle has become a viable option now that they're down to three, but we later see that wasn't actually the case, because it only has two cryotubes. A better argument, I think, is that at that point they simply no longer cared.

TonyPH

Other mistake: When Ripley is trying to deactivate the self-destruct mode, the instructions she follows on the container are actually just the French interpretation of the instructions she read to activate self-destruct before.

Jack Vaughan

More mistakes in Alien

Ripley: Did you ever ship out with Ash before?
Dallas: I went out five times with another science officer. They replaced him two days before we left Thedus with Ash. Hmm?
Ripley: I don't trust him.
Dallas: Well, I don't trust anybody.

More quotes from Alien

Trivia: The original budget for Alien was supposed to be $4.2 million, but was then doubled to $8.4 million after Ridley Scott impressed 20th Century Fox with the storyboards he made.

Casual Person

More trivia for Alien

Question: I recently saw this film at a local cinema and I noticed that there was a scene missing from when I first saw this film as a kid. In the aforementioned scene, Dallas is on the main computer (Mother) trying to get information about how to destroy the Alien. The computer just keeps responding with "Can not compute." He finally asks "What are my chances" and still gets the same response. I was wondering if anyone remembered this scene and knows why its been removed?

Gavin Jackson

Answer: If I'm not mistaken, the scene you're talking about (where Dallas consults Mother before going into the vent) was removed from the Director's Cut version of the film (which did get its own theatrical release in 2003). Perhaps that's the version they showed. I couldn't find the scene in its entirety, but is this what you're referring to? https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=OaoQES6C9ok.

Bishop73

Yes that was the scene. It was longer of course.

Gavin Jackson

More questions & answers from Alien