Directed by: Danny Cannon
Starring: Freddie Prinze Jr., Jennifer Love Hewitt, Mekhi Phifer, Brandy Norwood
Tyrell: Don't get her started all right. It's a long fucked up story and you probably won't believe it anyway. All I know is that this is the worst vacation of my life. I'm tired, I'm hungry, I'm fucking horny and I ain't seen one goddamn psycho killer.
Karla Wilson: "Try" is like "maybe," Julie. "Try" is bullshit.
Nancy: This island didn't have a murder rate until you people showed up.
Other mistake: When Karla and Ty are in the jacuzzi, the "Bob Marley" guy shows up and says they can't be there because it's after midnight. At the same time, the fisherman is killing the hotel's maid who is knocking on doors to clean the rooms. Why in the world does the cleaning lady do the housekeeping after midnight?
Question: Why did Estes attack Will with the paddle oar when he said "we're not going anywhere", and what did he mean by that?
Answer: I think that Estes already knew that Will was Ben's son. He had made a comment about a man (Ben) killing his wife (Sarah) in the same room Julie and Will was staying in. He also makes a comment about Will having his mother's eyes. So he probably recognized him. He also knew that the answer they gave to the radio host was wrong, and that proved it was a set up from the beginning.
I agree on most of the answer - although I am not sure about the part about the mother's eyes. What? He makes a passing comment about doing things on the island before Will was 'a gleam in his father's eye', which is just a figure of speech. The real question then is why, after the attack, he didn't do anything with him and just let him roam free.
Sammo ★