I Still Know What You Did Last Summer

Corrected entry: Brandy and Julie win a Caribbean trip after answering the question, "What is the capital of Brazil?" Their answer is "Rio de Janeiro". The capital of Brazil is "Brasilia"; it was moved from Rio de Janeiro to Brasilia in 1960.

Correction: The person doing the phony contest wanted the gang to come to the island so he could terrorize them, so he lied and said their answer was correct. This intentional misstatement is pointed out later in the movie.

Matty Blast

Corrected entry: I Know What You Did Last Summer was set in the summer of both 1997 and then 1998, making this film set in the summer of 1999. However written on Julie's grave is "Julie James 1979-1998" - it should be 1999. (01:10:15)

Hamster Premium member

Correction: The film is set in the summers of 1996 and then 1997, making I Still Know What You Did Last Summer set in 1998.


Corrected entry: When Julie sees Ben Willis at the club, he has two hands despite losing one in the first movie. (00:13:00)

Hamster Premium member

Correction: That's because he's not really there! Julie thinks he is but he's at the island waiting for her to arrive. She's seeing things.


Corrected entry: In "I Know What You Did Last Summer", David Egan dates Susie Willis, who they said is Ben Willis' daughter. In the sequel, Ben Willis' wife's name is Susie, and his daughter is Sara Willis.

Correction: When? I never heard that switched reference, and I'm watching it now. In addition, I did slow motion on the headstone scene when they see Julie's spray painted stone, and you can see Susan Willis born 1977, died 1996, Sarah Willis 1956-1980.


Corrected entry: When Brandy returns from outdoors soaking wet, she immediately reaches inside the door and pulls the "light switch", which is just a tangle of wires. Brandy would certainly have received an electric shock.

Correction: Not necessarily. Wet or not, to receive an electric shock she would have to have touched an exposed, live conductor. There is no proof that any of the conductors (the metal part) of those wires were exposed or live, or if so, that she actually touched the exposed, live part.


Corrected entry: When Tyrell gets hooked in the neck, the blood coming from his neck is obviously CG. It disappears into thin air, and none of it stains his tee-shirt or skin. (01:14:45)

Hamster Premium member

Correction: If you watch in slow motion you can see globs of blood dropping, but moving outward since he is flailing around. His movement along with the hooks prevent it from just flowing straight down, but it did not just disappear.


Corrected entry: How come there was absolutely NO mentioned of the final scene of I Know What You Did Last Summer? I understand that the writers may not have expected to do a sequel, but once they knew they were, they should have come up with SOME plausible way that Jennifer Love Hewitt escaped the attack in the steamy dorm shower at the end of the first movie.

Correction: This is actually explained in the film, although you have to listen carefully or you'll miss it. After Julie's dream at the beginning of the movie she goes out of the classroom and Will follows her. She tells him she had ANOTHER dream and he asks "The one in the shower?" referencing the end of the first film, to which she replies "No, the one in the church". So the end of the original film was just a dream. A cop out, but not a mistake.


Corrected entry: When Ben set up the fake accident scene, how did he know when and where Ray would be driving on that specific road?


Correction: It's possible he could have overheard Ray and his friend talking about it.

Factual error: At the end when Ben Willis and his son have Julie at the graves, Ray shows up with a gun. He fires at Ben but there is no bullet in the chamber. Later after the fight between Ray and Ben's son Julie picks up the six-shot gun and fires 8 shots at Ben.

Upvote valid corrections to help move entries into the corrections section.

Suggested correction: If you listen, while Julie is shooting, she shoots exactly five times. Meaning the six shot gun had one empty chamber and five bullets. The others just click as there are no more bullets.

I watched the clip on Youtube, and she shot more than 5 times which was before she continued to shoot a empty gun. The movie doesn't give evidence that she shot a loaded gun exactly 5 times because the 3 times she is shown shooting the amount is 5 shots, and it's obvious the Hook Man failed to attack Ray with his hook because Julie shot him. Hook Man reacts after the 1st shot, then Julie's shown shooting, and I heard another shot with the Hook Man shown. Then Julie shoots, and Hook Man reacts to that shot and another. Then Julie says the line that has the word die and is shown shooting exactly 3 times. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LgKIQbxZZgY.

I just watched and rewatched, she shot exactly FIVE times.

More mistakes in I Still Know What You Did Last Summer

Tyrell: Don't get her started all right. It's a long fucked up story and you probably won't believe it anyway. All I know is that this is the worst vacation of my life. I'm tired, I'm hungry, I'm fucking horny and I ain't seen one goddamn psycho killer.

More quotes from I Still Know What You Did Last Summer

Question: Was there any indication or hints that Will was actually Ben Willis' son before the reveal at the end?


Answer: I believe it was supposed to be a surprise plot twist, I don't remember there being any indication that Will was setting them up.

More questions & answers from I Still Know What You Did Last Summer

Join the mailing list

Separate from membership, this is to get updates about mistakes in recent releases. Addresses are not passed on to any third party, and are used solely for direct communication from this site. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Check out the mistake & trivia books, on Kindle and in paperback.