Continuity mistake: During the song "Home in in the Heart," Jason draws a house in the dirt, with a branch. In the first shot the drawing has no roof. In the next shot it suddenly does, and some of the drawn lines disappear as well.
Continuity mistake: When Nicholas is making the evil potion, he is about to put his shoe with gum on it, inside the cauldron. He hesitates, so the evil book forces the shoe to be thrown into the pot. However in the next shot Nicholas has two shoes back on his feet.
Continuity mistake: During the movie, the small red hearts on the Care Bears sides disappear and then reappear again between shots. This is most noticeable when Secret Bear and Friend Bear meet Kim and Jason in the park at the beginning.
Revealing mistake: When Tenderheart Bear confronts Nicholas in the Cave, the light of fire Nicholas has lit casts a shadow of Tenderheart Bear on the wall of the cave. However, when Tenderheart Bear moves his arms, the shadow stays the same.
Continuity mistake: In the song "It's Great to Be in the Care Bear Family," the Care Bear Cousins finally obtain their tummy symbols. However in a following shot Playful Heart Monkey is drawn without a symbol, even though he had only just obtained it.
Continuity mistake: In the shot where Kim and Jason slide down the rainbow with the Care Bears during the "Nobody Cares Like A Bear" song, Tenderheart is also on the rainbow. Tenderheart is actually on Earth trying to save Nicholas from the Evil Spirit at that very moment.
Continuity mistake: During the show while the children are laughing, a boy with a blue shirt and yellow hair is shown, however after the spell is cast he gets replaced with a boy with a gray sweater and dark brown hair.
Audio problem: When Nicholas casts the spell to make the kids fight, Tender Heart says "Nicholas what have you done?" His mouth is closed when he says "Nicholas."
Continuity mistake: When the kids are shown, the shirt color of the one with the blue suspenders keeps between orange and dark red.
