Question: When going to kill the Killians, how did the Horseman know that Thomas was hiding under the floor? Thomas stayed completely still and didn't make a sound.
Question: Why did Van Garret want to keep his marriage to Widow Winship a secret?
Question: Why was The Headless Horseman ordered to kill the Killian family including their incredibly young son?
Question: Why is it in one scene revealed that the headless horsemen is just a normal guy? That doesn't fit into the plot.
Question: What would have been the legal status of Widow Winship's unborn baby if the Horseman hadn't killed her or the baby?
Question: I am very confused about the incentives for killing these people was, why these people in particular were killed, and in general what was going on.
Question: What did Phillips mean when he said 5 bodies in 4 graves?
Question: What happened to Notary Hardenbrook? He just vanishes after the scene in the notary building where Ichabod finds the will, and there is no more mention of him in the film.
Question: Who was the father of Widow Winship's child?
Question: Why does Widow winship have a cut on her belly?