roy sandefur

9th Nov 2025

Overlord (2018)

Factual error: Fair twist on the WWII zombie genre. But this movie has the US army fully integrated, with blacks and whites fighting side by side, in the same units, during the D-Day invasion. This didn't happen until after the war.

roy sandefur

Factual error: This movie is set in the pre-Civil War Old West. At about 01:06:50, a slave, who is hoping to be taken to Mexico (where slavery is prohibited), is trying to bamboozle the lady played by Shelly Winters into believing he has vast astrological knowledge. And he points at the sky and mentions Pluto (which hadn't yet been discovered then). (01:06:50)

roy sandefur

1st Jun 2025

Lonesome Dove (1989)

Season 1 generally

Plot hole: When Ellie leaves Ft. Smith on a whiskey boat, she's just been seen with the morning sickness a day or two before. When she leaves the whiskey boat, somewhere between Arkansas and Nebraska, she says she's pregnant but is not showing at all. Even the snaggle-toothed frontier weirdo played by Steve Buscemi remarks that, "You ain't gonna be havin' no baby fer a while yet." The day she gets to Clara's, near Ogallala, Nebraska, she has the baby. Pregnancy lasts nine months. Morning sickness usually begins at about six weeks into it. Ft. Smith, Arkansas, to Ogallala is 561 miles. Even just walking three miles an hour for eight hours a day, one could make it in less than a month. But going via boat and mule-drawn wagon took her over seven months?

roy sandefur

3rd Apr 2025

The Godfather (1972)

Plot hole: When Michael is punched, the Don has just been shot and is near death. A gang war ensues and progresses. The Don recovers enough to be brought home. Michael moves to Italy, meets, courts, and marries his girl. Sonny is killed. Michael's wife learns to drive and is assassinated - and still, Michael has very visible remains of his black eye. Way too much time must have passed for this to be possible.

roy sandefur

11th Jan 2025

Streets of Laredo (1995)

Show generally

Factual error: In this final made-for-TV mini-series of the 'Lonesome Dove' franchise (the one with James Garner as Woodrow Call), they show the crazy renegade teenage killer hanging Judge Roy Bean from the beams outside the front of his own store/courthouse. Bean died peacefully in his bed on March 16, 1903, after a bout of heavy drinking in San Antonio.

roy sandefur

Other mistake: At just about the 2 hour point, a helicopter crashes into the back of a blue police van with such force that it crumples back the front half of the helicopter's fuselage like an accordion and causes it to explode in a huge fireball. In the next shot, we see that the back of the van has zero damage (from the helicopter crash, anyway - lots of bullet holes, but nary a dent in the back structure, nor even a scratch or burn mark on the dark blue paint). I guess you would call this an impossibility mistake. (02:00:00)

roy sandefur

21st May 2024

Bat*21 (1988)

Factual error: The two white jets they keep showing doing bombing runs, multiple times throughout this movie, are Air Force training jets, not combat aircraft.

roy sandefur

Upvote valid corrections to help move entries into the corrections section.

Suggested correction: The aircraft are F-5 Tigers... They are absolutely combat aircraft.

I looked up the F-5 Tiger, and those planes do look similar to what I saw in the movie, but also very similar to films of training jets I've seen. Whatever those things were in the movie, they carried no bombs or missiles; they just flew over, and then stuff went off on the ground. https://www.military.com/equipment/f-5-tigershark.

roy sandefur

OK - I think I found the answer - the F-5 Tiger is the combat aircraft and the F-5 Tigershark is the training version. They look almost the same but not quite.

roy sandefur

13th May 2024

Battles BC (2009)

26th Mar 2024

True Detective (2014)

Season 1 generally

Question: Was wondering why no explanation is ever given as to how and why Rust's weird ass, very detailed philosophy of space and time - with the crushed metal time disc and rotational electrical souls going around it forever etc. etc. - somehow is the exact same thing, right down to specific details, that at least three of the freaks, throughout this series, espouse. The underling freaks may espouse it because the main freak believes it - but we see Rust just arriving at it in his own mind.

roy sandefur

26th Mar 2024

True Detective (2014)

Season 1 generally

Factual error: A number of times throughout the season they refer to LSD being found in dead bodies and LSD being matched with other LSD found in other (living or dead) bodies. LSD starts a chain reaction in the brain which requires about an hour to take a noticeable effect. And, by that time, it has completely broken down and no longer exists as LSD in the body - before the person even begins to get high. There is no test for LSD even in the most bombed living individual, let alone a dead body years later.

roy sandefur

18th Jan 2024

The Revenant (2015)

Deliberate mistake: At about 1:49 in the movie, Glass is awakened by an attacking force of Arikara, and he fires his single-shot, muzzle-loading flintlock pistol at the nearest one coming at him. Then he runs to his nearby horse and flees, turning back to fire the gun a second time immediately. No reloading and no second gun on his person. It never leaves his hand; he's whacking the horse's rump with it to goad it on as soon as he jumps on it. And then he fires that same gun another time in a matter of seconds. (01:40:00)

roy sandefur

9th Oct 2023

The Martian (2015)

Stupidity: Very soon after Damon is stranded, one of the many satellites around Mars inevitably picks up the fact that he has moved various objects around his site, indicating that he's still alive. Yet it never occurs to him that this would obviously, eventually happen. In which case, his best option would be to simply spell out a message with debris and stay put instead of planning some 50-day journey.

roy sandefur

9th Oct 2023

The Martian (2015)

Question: After 400 days, the stranded astronaut's original, on-board, food ran out. After that, he lived on just potatoes for two or three more years (or something like that). He says, himself, "I have to grow three years' worth of food." The only food he grew was potatoes. Starch only - no lipids and no protein. For two or three years, to live on just potatoes? Is that even physically possible?

roy sandefur

Answer: I've seen the movie a few times, but did some additional Internet research. Watney was spreading out his 400 days of rations with the potatoes. I seem to recall him opening a small packet of a powdery substance and putting it on his food. Presumably it was vitamins, minerals, or other supplements. Of course, he was still severely malnourished when rescued.

raywest

Answer: The book explains it a bit more in depth. He had vitamins, minerals and supplements for six people, and NASA supplied enough for each person for a year, just in case some were damaged or spoiled... so he had plenty of vitamins. However, you can't live on just vitamins; you still have to have food... namely the potatoes.

Blathrop

Factual error: Throughout the movie, they depict the evil computer genius being able to manipulate (virtually any) distant objects, like video webcams and doorknobs, from his keyboard - just through sheer computer-genius awesomeness. When, to actually do these things, everything would have to be pre-rigged with servo motors and controllers, and be somehow connected on the web.

roy sandefur

Upvote valid corrections to help move entries into the corrections section.

Suggested correction: Well, many cameras do indeed have this feature. And of course, we only see the cases where it works, because what would be the point of showing the others? And they don't manipulate any doors that can't be reasonably expected to have a remote control option.

Show generally

Factual error: Near the beginning of the episode dealing with the life of Moses, they depict various scenes of ancient Egypt, during his time. But they show the Sphinx with the nose missing (as it looks today), when that face was intact until the early 19th century when Napoleon's troops used it for artillery target practice.

roy sandefur

Trivia: The scene where Quigley triggers a booby trap by swinging his rifle from horseback, at full gallop, whilst holding it by the tip of the barrel with one hand, was only possible because an alternate aluminum barrel was created for that scene.

roy sandefur

22nd Aug 2023

Battleline (1963)

20th Aug 2023

Open Range (2003)

Factual error: In the final shootout, a man is shot with a shotgun, and the blast comes through a wooden wall. It blows his body clean across an entire street outside the building, and he hits the wall of the building on the other side of that street. This never happens with firearms. No one is ever lifted off their feet, let alone blown across entire streets, etc. Physics declares that for this to happen, the shooter of the gun would have to be blown back with an equal and opposite force.

roy sandefur

Other mistake: Brian Keith sneaks into an Indian encampment at night while they are sleeping. In order to stampede their horses, he rapidly fires the one and only six-shooter revolver he has into the air...eight times.

roy sandefur

19th Aug 2023

Half Past Dead (2002)

Deliberate mistake: Early in the movie someone fires an RPG, and, when he does, they show him comically being flung back through the air by some kind of supposed recoil effect. RPGs are rockets shooting out of tubes with the blast going backwards, so the holder of the tube themselves experiences no recoil.

roy sandefur