Continuity mistake: Before the play when the man with the arm prostheses takes care of coats he is handed over a coat on his right hook and a hat on his left hook. When it cuts the coat is on his left hook and the hat is gone. (01:12:00)
Continuity mistake: As Violet approach the closet where the anchor is hanging she has her right hand up by her waist. When it cuts, it's down. (01:01:05)
Continuity mistake: When the Baudelaires arrives at the Curdled Cave and Aunt Josephine says "You deciphered the clues in my note" she is holding both hands over the edge of the rock on which she is lying. When it cuts only one of her hands are over the edge. (01:04:35)
Continuity mistake: As Violet and Klaus are looking over the edge of the broken house notice the broken planks. In the next shot the planks have changed. Some are shorter, some are longer. Definitely a different stage of scenery. (01:00:45)
Continuity mistake: When Mr. Poe is bringing the kids back from Monty, it cuts to a close-up shot inside the car of his hands on each side of the steering wheel. In the next shot his left hand is suddenly on top of the steering wheel. (00:45:20)
Continuity mistake: When Aunt Josephine hands over the photo album to Violet she hands it over with one hand. When it cuts she is holding it with both hands. (00:48:45)
Continuity mistake: When Count Olaf is driving the kids back from the custody hearing and the shot cuts from Olaf to the kids when Violet says, "Pure evil," Sunny is leaning against Violet, looking as if she is about to fall asleep. When the shot cuts back to Olaf, Sunny is sitting straight up and alert in between her siblings.
Continuity mistake: After Uncle Monty explains why they're going to Peru, he pulls back his jacket and puts his hands in his pockets, revealing the spyglass. In the next shot, his hands are behind his back, not in his pockets.
Continuity mistake: When Klaus throws the stick for Sunny to catch with her teeth he is holding a book with his left hand. His grip on the book change between the shots. (00:13:50)
Continuity mistake: When the Baudelaires arrive at Uncle Monty's and Monty says "We have to pack all the equipment" he has a snake whose head is over his shoulder. As Monty close the door it cuts and the snake's head is suddenly hanging down by his waist. (00:29:50)
Continuity mistake: When Count Olaf leaves the car on the train tracks and heads for the shop while locking the car doors with his remote, you can see that the mannequin's stop sign in its hand is pointing to the left. But when it cuts to Olaf hitting the sign it is pointing towards the camera. (00:22:55)
Chosen answer: On the beach, where Mr. Poe comes to inform them of the fire as the movie starts.