Plot hole: On her first night alone on the McBain farm, Jill hears someone playing a harmonica out there in the dark. She blows out a candle (but there is still plenty of light in the room), grabs a gun, positions herself at the brightly lit window, and shoots when the sees tha harmonica player lighting a match. This behavior is way too foolish for a women depicted as street-smart as Jill. (00:55:30)
Plot hole: When the Bigelows call Sackett out, Cap rises from his sickbed, takes a double-barrelled shotgun from over the door, breaks it open, and despite having used only a rifle and handgun up to this time, removes a couple of shotgun shells from his pocket and inserts them into the weapon.
Plot hole: No one hears the gunshot in the jail. The townspeople would come to see where the shot was fired. (01:39:28 - 01:39:52)
Plot hole: The Rangers arrive at the hideout when the lad following never got back to tell them where it was.
Plot hole: In the morning at the motel, the vampires have a big shoot-out with local law enforcement, which results in one at least one cop being killed. But when they escape, the police don't bother pursuing them or even giving them a another thought. Even for an 80's film, this is beyond ludicrous.
Plot hole: When the mechanical bull ride first opens up, riders need to pay $2 per ride and sign a waiver that if they get hurt, the bar is not responsible. But later in the film, riders (especially Bud) now just jump on and take a ride without paying (or signing but even if only needing to sign once, the money part is still in question here). How is it suddenly free?
Plot hole: At the beginning of the movie, Lady Sarah Ashley's husband is killed before Nullah rides to Faraway Downs. There he sees Sarah go into the home and find her dead husband. This would mean that somebody had to recover his body and transport it to Faraway Downs faster than Nullah, who went straight there following the murder.
Plot hole: The premise of the movie is nonsense. Thomas is a wanted man, with the largest bounty in history, even. He needs to lay low and deter his pursuers. So he heads out for a city, "Redemption," that happens to be populated entirely by wanted criminals who live there and lay low all together without anyone disturbing their peace. But he doesn't just "lay low;" he strikes a deal with the de facto mayor of Redemption so that they stage his hanging and burial in the local cemetery. Stage for who? At no point is it shown that the city cashed in the bounty; in fact, throughout the movie, several people try to cash it in still. Thomas just needed to be somewhere safe. The fact that he spread word that he is buried in that town only drew attention to the place, to no benefit for anyone. Literally, the last town in the West that needs publicity of that kind.