Michael Collins

Michael Collins (1996)

7 corrected entries

Corrected entry: The attack in the stadium happens in bright sunlight. When we see players and fans lying dead on the lawn there is no sun at all, but when the camera shows people running for cover the sun is back.

xx:xx:xx

NancyFelix

Correction: It being Ireland the sun does go behind clouds very quickly and back out again so this is quite possible.

Corrected entry: At the beginning of the first cabinet meeting after DeValera's return from America Aidan Quinn has difficulties suppressing a giggle and needs to cover his face, which is rather inappropriate considering the seriousness of the occasion.

xx:xx:xx

NancyFelix

Correction: Aidan is giggling over the fact that Michael Collins calls himself "a yob from West Cork" who is no good at talking and does not want to go to England to negotiate a treaty, feeling DeValera should. A serious scene, yes, but a comedic moment (for Harry) within.

Corrected entry: In the movie, G-man Ned Broy is caught burning incriminating documents and tortured to death by the black-and-tans. However, the real Ned Broy lived well into the 1940s, and went on to become chief of the Dublin Metropolitan Police.

Correction: As noted on the DVD and on IMDB, this movie employs a common technique often used in biopics: creating a single composite character out of multiple real people. When this is done, only 1 name can be used but the facts of the character are taken from each real person. In this case, the movie character Ned Broy was a composite of the real Ned Broy and of Dick McKee. The death portrayed did historically occur to McKee.

Corrected entry: When DeValera returns from America his formerly round spectacles are replaced by modern rimless ones, far ahead of the time the movie is set.

xx:xx:xx

NancyFelix

Correction: Eammon Devalera always wore rimless spectacles.

Corrected entry: In the scene where Michael Collins tries to enter the courts, bullet holes are to be seen before any fighting has started.

xx:xx:xx

Correction: As they were probably using the 4 courts the bullet holes were there since the civil war and therefore the original holes as in several buildings around Dublin.

Corrected entry: It's a well known fact that no one knew what Michael Collins looked like, and, according to the movie, there's only one photograph in his file that shows him more or less from behind. What doesn't fit into this picture is that we see him giving a public speech, watched by British (or British-paid) agents, which was one of many such speeches as Ned Broy later says.

xx:xx:xx

NancyFelix

Correction: There are several photographs of Michael Collins. Just look up any history textbook covering the civil war etc. or look him up on wikipedia.

Corrected entry: I wonder if Liam Neeson, age 44 at the time the movie was made and not looking any younger, was the right choice to play a 30-year-old freedom fighter.

NancyFelix

Correction: Liam Neeson looks a lot like Michael Collins. It couldnt have been cast any better.

Share

Follow