Other mistake: In the mid-credits scene, Kid and Doc obviously reveal their identity, tipping their hats much earlier than the cut, and repeat the motion in the following reaction shot, despite Kelly's continuous jibbering. (01:39:20)
Other mistake: When Thomas knocks one guy out, bashing his skull into the wagon, in the background there's an extra with a grey shirt who is not doing anything at all and just chills, watching the fight. (01:23:15)
Other mistake: Dynamite in the movie behaves in utterly unrealistic manners. It's some sort of incendiary bomb that causes an inferno of flames while leaving unharmed everyone else in the room, even in an enclosed space. But it's also inconsistent, because later in the movie both good and bad guys use the same dynamite again, and it causes zero flames. (01:14:40)
Other mistake: The morning after the dark, stormy night, an establishing shot outside of the saloon shows a bunch of dead people in the middle of the street that weren't there the night before, nor will be there after. (01:11:35)
Other mistake: Valerie, in front of the mirror, checks out the little boil left from spelunking inside her flesh earlier in the day. She moves with Thomas into a different room. She flirts with him, laying it on thick, and her thigh is now immaculate. (01:09:50)
Other mistake: When Jericho and Bella arrive at the end of the cave where he stashed away all the belongings of the 'baptized', the room is already lit by a torch. It's not a place where people would hang out daily, keeping lit torches in perpetuity. (00:52:30)
Other mistake: When Doc spots Thalia's accomplices after chasing her in vain, there are roughly 20 extras. Later on, Doc says that they are 'a hundred men, maybe more'. And he's right! But that's not what he saw or was shown. (00:24:20 - 00:28:25)
Other mistake: Valerie rents a room that wasn't even supposed to be available, goes right upstairs carrying just a plate with flatbread for her daughter. She does not have a single moment to even take off her coat, but still the room in the rest of the scene has two lit lamps, conveniently placed alcohol for her Terminator-like surgery, and jam for her daughter. (00:19:45)
Other mistake: Thomas' horse does not bat an eyelash even when supposedly it's being hit by bullets at least twice right at that moment, leaving a massive blood spray on Thomas' face. (00:05:35)
