Corrected entry: In the Scene where Det. Cassidy is confronting Dr. Sachs in his office about the death of his girlfriend, he says "this wasn't part of the plan". She continues to question him and slams down the mug shots of the gang of criminals. Dr. Sachs points at Patrick's picture and says "He said I had until 5:00". How does Dr. Sachs know that Patrick is the ringleader of the group? He has only spoken to him on the phone and never saw him.
Corrected entry: When the kidnappers are contacting Conrad for the first time, he realises they can see him and goes to shut the curtains, while doing so the hand with the phone reaches over, away from his ear, to pull the drapes yet he hears the bad guy say "Don't close the curtains."
Corrected entry: In the scene where Dr. Conrad is trying to get to the hospital and breaks through the parade, he leaves the bad guy on the motorcycle behind him. Next, he arrives at the hospital and seconds later the bad guy is there. If the guy on the motorcycle didn't get to cut through the parade as Dr. Conrad did, how come he arrived that fast? Technically, he would have had to go all the way around the parade therefore, arriving much later than Dr. Conrad.
Corrected entry: Since the bad guys know that the girl's father was to be buried as a John Doe, and since they read in the paper that she was found wandering on Hart's Island a couple of days after his death, they had to know that the doll was somewhere on the island - isn't that why they were looking for the 6-digit number? So why didn't they use their technical expertise to find out which graves were dug during that timeframe? Seems easier than the killing, kidnapping, camera & mikes, etc.
Corrected entry: At the dock before setting off for the island, which lies a short distance away, it's light outside. When they arrive at the island, it's dark.
Corrected entry: The whole movie is based on the fact that they need the number the girl has,yet they have no idea what the number is from. How would they even know she had this number? They don't know where she is, they don't know what the number is, they just somehow know that there is a number.
Corrected entry: Take a look at the girl in the morgue. The first shot, from below her right side shows her right breast, the next shot, above her, shows no breasts, and the same shot afterwards shows a flat chest. Are these magical disappearing boobs? (00:35:28)