Character mistake: The Nostalgia Critic says, "Imagine if Lofi Girl listened to a compilation of him instead of her laid-back music." But he foolishly mispronounces "Lofi Girl" as "Loffy Girl." (00:23:11)
Pearl Harbor - S6-E3
Character mistake: Nostalgia Critic states that once Affleck goes to the war, he spends his time in "fighter jets." But while saying this, shows him in a WWII propeller powered fighter plane. (00:11:10)
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 2014 - S8-E12
Continuity mistake: When Nerd is saying "Babble science babble science babble science." it is on a close up of him and he looks to the right of the screen. It cuts to a wide shot of him next to Critic and suddenly he's looking to the left towards Critic. (00:08:40)
That Darn Cat (1997) - S12-E32
Nostalgic Critic: How am I supposed to focus on the watch when the top of the Technodrome is emerging from her thumb!? (00:12:40)
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 2014 - S8-E12
Trivia: The guy playing the stand in for Vanilla Ice and singing is actually YouTube star Brentalfloss. (00:23:22)