Ann Bonnie: If you're angry about the whore and me, just fucking say so. Jack Rackham: You have an itch that needs scratching, go with God. My trouble isn't that she knows how to play the thing between your legs better than I do, but the one between your ears.
Thomas Hamilton: We can't get an honest man appointed governor in the Bahamas. James McGraw: You can get him appointed, the problem seems to be keeping him honest thereafter.
Plot hole: Why, of all people on board, would the cook know of a specific entry in the captain's log, exactly where to look for it, and that it contained very valuable information?