Question: Why couldn't Miss Peregrine create a loop sooner? Surely there were safer days before the bomb hit her house.
Question: How did Abe know at the end that the peculiar children were still in Blackpool and hadn't left on their ship yet?
Question: Why doesn't Millard just sneak past the wights in the Blackpool Tower and free the Ymbrynes from the cellar himself? Also, why doesn't he do more during the final battle?
Question: How does Emma manage to get out of the ocean with her lead shoes on? She couldn't have swum all the way to the shore.
Question: What is the deal with Emma's underwear? We see her wearing shorts when she goes swimming, but other times her underwear goes over her knees.
Question: Why doesn't Barron just sneak into Abe's house, scour his map for the location of Miss Peregrine's loop, and travel to Wales disguised as Jake to find it? It probably would have saved him a lot of time and trouble, instead of posing as a psychiatrist and an ornithologist, and manipulating Jake into leading him to Miss Peregrine?
Question: Where did the horse and cart come from? And what did the children do with them afterwards?
Question: How is Emma sitting on the horse and cart when she is lighter than air? I have watched the movie a few times and cannot see anything like a belt around her waist, but any other time she is sitting, she has been seen buckled down.
Answer: This is a movie mistake because when she's at dinner, she has to wear a buckle to hold her down. And I don't see why she wouldn't be wearing one on the carriage too.
Question: Why do Miss Peregrine and the children wear the same outfits every day? Don't they have other clothes?





Chosen answer: At several points throughout the film, there are instances where her powers of air are used only as a plot device, so the extent of her powers is somewhat unknown. Therefore, it is possible she is able to make herself sit on the cart without floating, but other times isn't.
Amina Thommesen-Kähler