Starring: John McIntire, Frank McGrath, Robert Horton, Terry Wilson
The Candy O'Hara Story - S4-E11
Factual error: The characters visit Aurora, Colorado. The series takes place in 1860s-1870s - at the time it was named Fletcher. (00:06:25)
Factual error: The wagon master is sitting drinking a cup of coffee, and he has two bandaids on the first and second finger of his hand. Bandaids were not introduced until the 1920's.
Revealing mistake: When Jan Clayton picks up the baby to go outside and torch the wagon, she swings the baby around carelessly, revealing the shiny (and unsettling) head of an old prop baby doll. (00:37:15)
The Heather Mahoney Story - S5-E37
Question: After stopping the runaway carriage, the wagon master gets off his horse. The ladies speak a bit, then Heather Mahoney says, "Mr. Hale, I am determined to express my gratitude for your kindness even if my mother isn't." When did Mr. Hale exchange pleasantries with Mrs. Mahoney prior to stopping the carriage? (00:03:00 - 00:07:00)