Best book continuity mistakes of all time

Please vote as you browse around to help the best rise to the top.

Continuity mistake: Tom's jacket keeps reappearing constantly. He leaves it down in the tunnels in the beginning and is unable to go back and get it, yet after the lecture he gives it to Paul. Then when Paul and Tom are leaving the library Tom is magically wearing the jacket again.

More The Rule of Four continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: Earlier in the series Amber says her teacher Mrs. Holt's name is Roberta, because she says "I think it should be Reporta". But in this book, she's making Christmas gifts having to do with her initials and she says her name is Olivia Holt.

More I, Amber Brown continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: When Ethelred is reading out the cockatrices' plans to the massed mythical creatures, one of them refers to "All dragons" pulling carts. What dragons? They stole the last dragon eggs from Tabitha to make dragons extinct.

More The Talking Parcel continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: While hearing Fergus and Marsali having intercourse to get Marsali's labor started, Claire reflects on the same thing working for her to start her labor with Brianna. But in Voyager Claire mentions how having sex with Frank was an impossibility because her pregnancy was so dangerous.

More A Breath of Snow and Ashes continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: Chapter Seven A: Post Haste. When Stanley shows Moist the new stamps it says "The boy put a sheet of stamps on the desk." But then Moist snatches the sheet from Stanley's hand.

More Going Postal continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: In chapter 9, Fireheart takes Cinderpaw to see the Thunderpath. He asks her if she can smell anything apart from the monsters, she replies that she can smell shadowclan because she smelt the same scent on the kits that were taken: 'I remember that scent from when brokenstar attacked our camp. And it was on the kits he took'. But if you read the paragraph about finding the kits in shadowclan (very end of chapter 24 in Into the Wild) it says that "the last one was grey, like the embers of an old fire" and that she is a girl. The description sounds like Cinderpaw, and she is one of Frostfur's kits (like the ones who were taken), which means Cinderpaw was taken but says the scent was on the ones he took, meaning she wasn't one.

More Warriors: Fire and Ice continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: In the chapter called "The Park," when Grant sees the T-Rex, he states that the T-Rex was sleeping by the killed hadrosaur. Then later on in the same chapter, it says the juvenile T-Rex stood over the T-Rex's killed sauropod. It even goes on to say that the juvenile T-Rex steals a piece of meat from this sauropod and runs away with it. Sauropods and hadrosaurs are different dinosaurs.

More Jurassic Park continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: The detective Kinsey Millhone is looking through her closet for something to wear to a party and comes across a green cocktail dress that was given to her in E is for Evidence that she "forgot she had". However, in E is for Evidence, Kinsey was hurt in a bomb blast and specifically says that this dress was cut off her in the emergency room so her wounds could be treated. Even if she bothered having the dress repaired, it was unlikely she would have forgotten about it, especially under the circumstances.

More R is for Ricochet continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: In 'Horrid Henry', Peter says that beetroot is his favourite, but in 'Horrid Henry dines at restaurant le posh', Peter says that he eats everything apart from beetroot.

jonnyb

More Horrid Henry continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: When Evanlyn tells Will her real name on Skorghijl we hear Will's thoughts, he thinks that he is afraid of betraying Evanlyn to someone who has sworn to kill all of her family. It isn't until later that Will finds out that the oath Ragnak has given is to kill all of Evanlyn's family.

More Ranger's Apprentice: The Icebound Land continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: Towards the end of the book (p. 361 in my paperback edition) there is a chapter called "The Fifteenth Day: Friday, 17 December." The mistake is that the next chapter is called "The Sixteenth Day: Saturday, 17 December". The book has December 17th occurring two days in a row.

Aerinah

More The Hunt for Red October continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: In "A Kiss of Shadows" by Laurell K Hamilton at the beginning of chapter 8 it states that "It's eight o'clock Friday night". At the beginning of chapter 10 it says "Eight o'clock on a Saturday night". Between these two chapters only and hour or so of time has passed by. So which day is it, Friday or Saturday?

More A Kiss of Shadows continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: In the previous book, Dark Assassin, Monk goes through Durban's notes and finds the only case of his which "remained a mystery" (Ch. 7). The case Monk reopens in the next book, Execution Dock, is also repeatedly referred to as "the one case Durban had not solved" (e.g., Ch. 1 and Ch. 5). The mistake is that there is no way these are the same case. The one from Dark Assassin involves the murder of a 40-year-old barber named Roger Thorwood; the one from Execution Dock is the sexual abuse and murder of a boy named Walter Figgis, by a man named Jericho Phillips. None of the suspects, victims, or witnesses in the two cases overlap at all. Of course Durban could have worked on both cases - but they can't both be the one single case he never solved. And if they are both unfinished, then it is wrong to say (as the author does repeatedly in Execution Dock) that there is only one case Durban didn't close. (It also can't be a character mistake on Monk's part, since he knows about both cases).

Aerinah

More Execution Dock continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: In Ch. 72, Stu describes finding Harold dead, and recalls that "Harold still clutched the Permacover notebook in one stiffening hand." But earlier, in Ch. 64, Stephen King states that Harold "put the Permacover notebook into the Triumph's saddlebag" immediately before shooting himself.

Aerinah

More The Stand continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: When Decker is reviewing the witness statements, he read that Melissa Dalton was at school early to take a make-up test, due to missing it for an illness. He then immediately notes that she had perfect attendance; she hadn't even had a tardy.

SomeSweetGirl

More Memory Man continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: On page 305 of the first edition published 2012, Piper and Annabeth sent a dream vision to Camp Half-Blood, but on page 306 they refer to it as an Iris-message.

Meawesome828

More The Mark of Athena continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: There's something funny going on with time in Chapters 20-21. Barney rescues Valancy from the rowdy dance shortly after 11 pm (Ch. 20), and takes her away in his car, which runs out of gas. They sit and talk for a long time (Ch. 21), until Valancy's uncle and cousin drive up. which supposedly happens at 10 pm - an hour before they even left. And Valancy tells her cousin Olive that she's been sitting there with Barney for three hours.

More The Blue Castle continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: Chapter 16 states that Tom Mahout's eyes are grey. His eyes were mentioned as being bright blue at the end of Chapter 31.

More Gerald's Game continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: When the three grandparents take an overdose of Willy Wonka's Wonkavite, it is revealed that their ages are around 80 years and Grandma Georgina is in fact 78. When introduced in Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, it is stated that all of them are above the age of 90.

More Charlie and the Great Glass Elevator continuity mistakes

Continuity mistake: Alex is introduced to his fellow CIA agent, Tom Turner. Later, his name becomes Taylor. It proceeds to alternate throughout the book - changing within two paragraphs on page 128.

More Skeleton Key continuity mistakes

Join the mailing list

Separate from membership, this is to get updates about mistakes in recent releases. Addresses are not passed on to any third party, and are used solely for direct communication from this site. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Check out the mistake & trivia books, on Kindle and in paperback.