Emily

Continuity mistake: When the Lost Boys see that they have shot down Wendy, they turn around and say "Tootles has killed her" and they are spread out, but when Peter comes in a second later, they are grouped together. (00:34:15)

Emily

Continuity mistake: When John tries to fly for the first time, he jumps off the bed and we see him soar across the room, but the room is nowhere near long enough for him to have gone as far as he did before he crashed. (00:21:30)

Emily

Continuity mistake: During the scene at lunch when Dewey is telling the teachers a story, we see that the teacher who is sitting at the end of the table near Dewey is pretty close to him, but after Dewey tells the "gym teacher joke" we get a view of the table and the teacher that was nearest Dewey is farther away than before. (00:49:00)

Emily

Continuity mistake: In the scene where Dewey tells the class that he is going to be singing and playing guitar, Alicia says something like "Why are you in the band?" and the shot is of her back with her right arm behind her chair, but when the shot changes so you see the front of her, her arm is in front of her chair on the desk. This happens several times. (00:31:20)

Emily

Continuity mistake: In the scene after Wendy kisses Peter, Peter comes back down from the sky and cuts the ropes binding Hook. Hook is still tangled in the ropes when Peter tosses him a sword, but in the next shot, Hook flies away from the ropes as if he wasn't ever tangled in them. There wasn't enough time in between shots for him to cut the ropes himself. (01:32:05)

Emily

Continuity mistake: Peter is on the cloud looking through the telescope to see the Jolly Roger. Peter says "let's get a closer look" to Wendy, Michael and John, and he does a front-flip with the telescope in his hand, in the next shot the telescope is gone, but then he has it again a minute later. (00:30:25)

Emily

Continuity mistake: In the scene where Peter ducks down next to the Lost Boys, we see Hook look at the boys and Peter is in the far right, but as Hook comes closer, Peter is now in the middle (it would have been impossible for him to slide into the middle because Hook would have noticed it). (01:22:45)

Emily

Continuity mistake: When Ron opens up the howler his mom sent him, the howler rises up to face Ron and Ron has direct eye contact with it, but if you watch closely you can see that Harry's eye contact is not correct. (00:34:40)

Emily