Factual error: In Joe's Adventures, there is the level called "Supermarket" where the Empire Bay Police Department sends in the SWAT team to confront you. This mission takes place in 1951. SWAT was not invented and utilised until the mid-1960s.
Continuity mistake: Vito is imprisoned in May of '45. He is in prison 17 days when he receives news of his mother's death. The letter is postmarked Jan 25th.
Answer: The fictional town is supposedly located somewhere on New York's coast, near the mouth of the Culver River, also fictional.
raywest